Accounts of Psychological and Emotional Well-Being for Policy Purposes
Societal Differences
PY806

Accounts of Psychological and Emotional Well-Being for Policy Purposes

10 min read . Free to read and download

Free module. We recommend you sign up free to start the lessons, so that your progress, notes and journal are saved.

What makes a good life? This deceptively simple question has profound implications for how governments shape policy, allocate resources and measure success. When a nation chooses to prioritise happiness, it makes different choices than one prioritising economic growth. When wellbeing means freedom from suffering rather than realising your potential, the policies that follow will diverge. Yet most policy makers have rarely paused to ask which conception of wellbeing should guide their decisions.

Psychological science offers multiple, competing accounts of wellbeing. Some emphasise pleasant feelings and life satisfaction; others stress meaning, growth and purpose. Some highlight universal human needs; others insist that wellbeing is culturally constructed. This module explores these rival frameworks and asks why the choice between them matters enormously for public policy across the world.

Hedonic and Eudaimonic Approaches to Wellbeing

The oldest tradition in wellbeing research draws from hedonism: the view that life goes well when we experience pleasure and satisfaction and minimise pain and dissatisfaction. This hedonic account underlies much of modern wellbeing science, particularly research using subjective measures like life satisfaction scales and mood questionnaires. When the Gallup World Poll asks people whether they are satisfied with their lives, or when the UK Office for National Statistics measures life satisfaction on a scale of zero to ten, they are capturing something hedonic: how people evaluate their lives overall and whether they feel good day to day.

Yet another tradition, far older, holds that hedonic pleasure misses something essential. The eudaimonic approach, rooted in Aristotle, proposes that wellbeing consists in living well according to your nature, in developing your potential and in pursuing meaningful activity. A person might feel satisfied yet hollow; might experience daily pleasure yet lack purpose. Eudaimonic wellbeing asks whether you are growing, whether your life feels meaningful, whether you are becoming the person you want to be. The OECD guidance on measuring wellbeing acknowledges both dimensions, distinguishing between evaluative wellbeing (how satisfied you are with life), experienced wellbeing (how you feel day to day) and eudaimonic wellbeing (meaning and purpose). This distinction has real consequences. A policy that maximises pleasure might not maximise meaning. A society that feels satisfied might not feel purposeful.

Psychological Well-Being Dimensions and Self-Determination

Carol Ryff developed a framework identifying six core dimensions of psychological wellbeing: autonomy, environmental mastery, personal growth, positive relations with others, purpose in life and self-acceptance. This multidimensional view suggests that wellbeing is not a single thing to be measured but a constellation of human flourishing. Autonomy speaks to feeling in control of your life and decisions; environmental mastery to managing practical demands; personal growth to developing and improving; positive relations to feeling connected and supported; purpose to having direction and meaning; self-acceptance to valuing yourself and your life.

Self-determination theory, developed by Deci and Ryan, identifies three psychological needs as fundamental to wellbeing: autonomy (feeling in control rather than controlled), competence (feeling capable and effective) and relatedness (feeling connected to others and valued by them). Unlike frameworks that assume wellbeing is culturally relative, self-determination theory proposes these needs are universal. Satisfaction of these needs predicts wellbeing across diverse cultures. This matters for policy. If autonomy, competence and relatedness are truly universal needs, then policies that undermine them damage wellbeing everywhere. A welfare system that creates dependency without choice might satisfy material needs yet frustrate autonomy. A school system that focuses only on test scores might develop competence narrowly whilst neglecting relatedness and purpose.

The Capabilities Approach and Objective List Theories

Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum developed the capabilities approach, arguing that wellbeing depends on what people are actually able to do and become. This reframes the question from how people feel to what real freedoms and opportunities they have. The approach identifies central capabilities: practical reason, affiliation, bodily integrity, emotional health, imagination and play, and others. A person might report high life satisfaction whilst lacking genuine capability to leave an abusive relationship, to vote freely, to read, to work in a chosen field. Conversely, someone might struggle emotionally yet have rich capabilities and genuine agency.

Objective list theories propose that certain things are genuinely good for wellbeing regardless of whether people desire them: knowledge, health, achievement, authentic relationships, freedom, justice. These theories challenge the assumption that wellbeing is entirely subjective. They propose that you can be mistaken about what makes you flourish. Someone socialised into very limited aspirations might report satisfaction with constrained circumstances yet lack access to goods that would genuinely improve their life. The capabilities approach and objective list theories shift policy focus away from simply measuring happiness toward ensuring people have real freedoms, opportunities and access to goods that enable flourishing. New Zealand's Wellbeing Budget reflects this thinking, prioritising genuine capability to participate in society, not merely subjective satisfaction.

Cultural Diversity in Concepts of the Good Life

What constitutes a good life varies meaningfully across cultures, and wellbeing research must respect this diversity rather than imposing a single global standard. Research from scholars examining diverse societies reveals different emphasis and meaning. In some cultures, individual achievement, autonomy and personal satisfaction are central; in others, family harmony, social duty and collective wellbeing take priority. Individualistically oriented societies tend to emphasise personal growth, self-expression and autonomy as wellbeing dimensions; collectivist societies often prioritise relational harmony, social contribution and fitting well within community.

Bhutan's Gross National Happiness framework exemplifies culturally specific wellbeing philosophy, emphasising psychological wellbeing alongside sustainable development, good governance and cultural preservation. The framework reflects Buddhist and Bhutanese values prioritising spiritual and collective wellbeing over individual consumption. Similarly, many African conceptions of wellbeing centre Ubuntu: the philosophy that personhood emerges through relationship with others and community. These are not exotic alternatives to real wellbeing; they represent genuine, coherent visions of flourishing. Policy makers must ask whether wellbeing frameworks imported from wealthy Western nations reflect the actual values and priorities of the people they serve. When Nordic countries measure wellbeing, they emphasise work-life balance and social trust reflecting their particular cultural and historical contexts. These are not universal truths but culturally grounded choices.

Policy Consequences of Different Well-Being Accounts

The choice between hedonic, eudaimonic and capabilities-based accounts transforms which policies get prioritised. A government committed to hedonic wellbeing might focus on reducing pain, expanding entertainment and leisure, and ensuring material comfort. This leads naturally toward economic growth strategies, consumer choice, healthcare focused on symptom relief and policies expanding leisure time. A government committed to eudaimonic wellbeing prioritises conditions for meaning-making, skill development and purposeful engagement. This might mean investing in arts, education, volunteering infrastructure and work arrangements that allow mastery and growth even if less profitable. A capabilities-focused government asks whether people have genuine freedom to participate in civic life, education, employment and relationships. This emphasises access, removes barriers and builds infrastructure for genuine choice.

Wales's Well-being of Future Generations Act requires public bodies to consider whether their decisions improve wellbeing, defined broadly as physical, mental and social wellbeing alongside economic and cultural wellbeing and environmental protection. This multidimensional approach shifts priorities. The Office for National Statistics in the United Kingdom includes alongside life satisfaction questions about anxiety, loneliness, meaning in life and sense of purpose. Including meaning and purpose alongside satisfaction signals that policy should address all dimensions, not merely pleasure or satisfaction. When governments adopt objective list approaches, they might prioritise access to nature, social connection, educational opportunity and meaningful work even when individuals report being satisfied without them.

Measuring What Matters: From Single Indicators to Multidimensional Frameworks

Early wellbeing research often relied on single measures: life satisfaction on a ten-point scale, annual happiness surveys, or simply gross domestic product as a proxy for wellbeing. Single measures have advantages: they are simple to gather, compare and understand. Yet they obscure crucial dimensions. The OECD Better Life Index and its guidelines for measuring wellbeing moved toward multidimensional approaches capturing work-life balance, civic engagement, environmental quality, health, education, social connection and subjective wellbeing alongside material living standards. The United Nations World Happiness Report synthesises data on life evaluation, positive and negative emotions and social support across nations, recognising that wellbeing requires multiple dimensions.

This shift matters profoundly for policy. If a government measures only economic growth, it sets priorities accordingly. If it measures life satisfaction and nothing else, it might miss inequalities, injustices and lacking opportunities that undermine flourishing. If it measures subjective wellbeing plus capabilities, meaning and social connection, it sets far broader goals. The Nordic welfare states demonstrate this: by measuring and prioritising multiple dimensions including social trust, work satisfaction, health, education and family time alongside material living standards, they have built societies where people report high wellbeing across multiple dimensions. The challenge for policy globally is choosing which dimensions to measure and prioritise, knowing that this choice shapes which public goods get funded, which private choices get supported, and which aspects of human flourishing get neglected.

Synthesis: Pluralism, Values and Democratic Choice

No single wellbeing account is objectively correct. Hedonic, eudaimonic, capabilities and objective list approaches each capture something true about human flourishing and each implies different policy priorities. The frameworks overlap considerably: most wellbeing accounts include elements of pleasure, meaning, agency, relationships and material security. Yet they differ fundamentally in emphasis and in what counts as wellbeing when these goods conflict.

This plurality is not a problem to be solved but a feature to be managed carefully. Different societies, with different histories, values and challenges, may reasonably prioritise different wellbeing dimensions. The question is not which framework is universal but rather which framework reflects a society's actual values and addresses its genuine needs. This requires democratic deliberation. What do the people in this country believe constitutes a good life? What dimensions of wellbeing matter most? What trade-offs are they willing to accept? These are fundamentally political and cultural questions, not technical ones. Psychology and evidence can clarify the options, illustrate consequences and show what works. But societies must decide for themselves which conception of wellbeing should guide their policies. The growing international movement toward wellbeing-centred policy, visible in New Zealand, Wales, Scotland and beyond, represents collective recognition that economic growth alone misdirects policy toward flourishing. The frameworks explored here offer different pathways toward more human-centred governance. The challenge ahead is ensuring that policy makers and citizens engage thoughtfully with these frameworks and make explicit, democratically legitimate choices about what wellbeing means in their particular context.

Summary

  • —Hedonic wellbeing emphasises pleasant feelings and life satisfaction, whilst eudaimonic wellbeing stresses meaning, growth and purpose; most comprehensive policy frameworks now measure both dimensions.
  • —Ryff's psychological wellbeing dimensions and self-determination theory propose that autonomy, competence and relatedness are universal human needs that predict flourishing across cultures.
  • —The capabilities approach and objective list theories shift focus from subjective feelings toward genuine freedoms and opportunities, recognising that people can be mistaken about what enables flourishing.
  • —Cultural diversity means that what constitutes a good life varies meaningfully; Bhutan's Gross National Happiness and Ubuntu philosophy exemplify culturally specific but coherent wellbeing visions.
  • —Choosing between wellbeing accounts directly shapes which policies get prioritised, funded and implemented; hedonic, eudaimonic and capabilities approaches lead to substantially different governance.
  • —Democratic societies must make explicit choices about which wellbeing dimensions to prioritise, recognising that this choice is fundamentally political and reflects their values and needs.

Vocabulary

hedonic wellbeing

wellbeing understood as the experience of pleasure, satisfaction and positive feelings, and the minimisation of pain and negative emotions

eudaimonic wellbeing

wellbeing understood as living according to your potential, developing capabilities, finding meaning and pursuing purposeful activity

autonomy

the experience of having genuine choice and control over your decisions and life direction rather than being controlled by external forces

capabilities approach

a framework viewing wellbeing not as subjective feelings but as the genuine freedoms and opportunities people have to do and become what they value

self-determination theory

a psychological framework proposing that wellbeing depends on satisfying three universal needs: autonomy, competence and relatedness

objective list theory

an account holding that certain things are genuinely good for wellbeing regardless of whether people desire them, such as knowledge, health or authentic relationships

multidimensional wellbeing

an approach measuring wellbeing across multiple domains including material living standards, health, education, work, social connection, civic engagement and environmental quality

evaluative wellbeing

how people assess their lives overall and their satisfaction with their circumstances, typically measured on rating scales

experienced wellbeing

the emotions and feelings people experience day to day, including positive emotions, negative emotions and mood states

Critical Thinking Questions

  1. 1.If you could increase people's life satisfaction without increasing their sense of meaning or purpose, would this represent genuine progress for a society? Why or why not?
  2. 2.Some people report high life satisfaction within deeply constrained circumstances. How should policy makers distinguish between satisfied acceptance and constrained aspirations that have been limited by circumstance?
  3. 3.Which dimensions of wellbeing do you believe should be prioritised in your own society, and why? How would different priorities change policy choices about education, work, health or the environment?
  4. 4.If wellbeing means different things across cultures, how should international bodies like the United Nations develop policies that respect cultural difference while protecting genuine human needs and freedoms?
  5. 5.Some argue that prioritising wellbeing over economic growth might reduce resources available for investment and innovation. How would you weigh these concerns against potential benefits of wellbeing-centred policy?

This module is an original work by BWGELA, shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 licence. BWGELA, in the spirit of OER, grants the reader the same Creative Commons Licence, to include the attribution: 'Accounts of Psychological and Emotional Well-Being for Policy Purposes' by BWGELA @ www.bwgela.com 2026.

A weekly article to stimulate the mind

Critical Thinking to start your week. No Obligation. No Sales. No Credit Card.