
Occasionalism and Divine Causality: The Critique of Necessary Natural Causes
Written by The Pilgrim ·
Can we ever truly know that fire causes burning, or do we merely assume it from habit? What does that uncertainty reveal about the foundations of our reasoning? And if the greatest minds of two entirely different civilisations, separated by six centuries and a vast cultural ocean, arrived at the same unsettling doubt independently, what does that convergence tell us about the limits of human inference?
Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, the eleventh-century Persian theologian, jurist and mystic, is one of those thinkers who rewards patient reading in a way that few others do. His reputation in the medieval Islamic world was formidable, and his work The Incoherence of the Philosophers remains one of the most ambitious and rigorous exercises in philosophical critique that the pre-modern world produced. His target was the Aristotelian-inflected rationalism of thinkers such as Ibn Sina, who held that the natural world operates through necessary causal connections built into the very natures of things. Al-Ghazali found this claim philosophically presumptuous and theologically dangerous, and he set out to dismantle it with a precision that still commands respect.
Subscribe free to keep reading
Audio episode: 7 minutes
Subscribe with your email to read every article, listen to the audio and use the libraries. Already a subscriber? Enter your email once on this device and everything opens.
No Ads. No Sales. No Credit Card.
By subscribing you agree to receive the BWGELA newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Have an account?
Questions to Ponder
- 1.
When you observe regularity in your own life, how would recognising the gap between sequence and necessity change the confidence you place in your predictions about tomorrow?
- 2.
If the mind projects necessity onto the world through habit rather than reading it off from observation, what does this reveal about how we distinguish between genuine knowledge and comforting assumption?
- 3.
Given that al-Ghazali and Hume reached similar sceptical conclusions from radically different philosophical starting points, what might this convergence suggest about the limits of reason itself across all human thinking?
- 4.
How should societies make decisions about natural systems and technological risks if the causal confidence underlying those systems rests ultimately on habit rather than demonstrated necessity?
or to write private answers and keep them in My Journal.
BWGELA, in the spirit of OER, grants the Creative Commons Licence CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 to the reader, to include the attribution: ‘Occasionalism and Divine Causality: The Critique of Necessary Natural Causes’ scripted by the Pilgrim BWGELA @ www.bwgela.com 2026.